The Great Dot Grid Versus Lined Debate
We asked twelve writers which ruling they reach for, and nobody agreed.
Few topics fill our inbox faster. Dot grid people call lined paper rigid; lined people call dot grid indecisive. Both sides are right about something.
Where each ruling wins
After a month of swapping notebooks between writers, the answer depended less on taste than on what each person was trying to write.
- Lined for long letters and drafts.
- Dot grid for lists, diagrams, and layouts.
- Blank for sketches and calligraphy practice.
- Graph for anyone who secretly loves tables.
“Sir, more than kisses, letters mingle souls; for, thus friends absent speak.”
— John Donne, “To Sir Henry Wotton” (c. 1597)

I laughed at the bit about losing the loupe. Mine is in a drawer I cannot find.
Seconding this. A follow-up would be great.
There is a good thread about this in the reader mailbag from last spring.
Came for the pens, stayed for the writing. Subscribed to the newsletter.
I laughed at the bit about losing the loupe. Mine is in a drawer I cannot find.
Would love to see your results if you try it.
Would love to see your results if you try it.
I laughed at the bit about losing the loupe. Mine is in a drawer I cannot find.