Vol. VII  ·  No. 38  ·  The Autumn Folio Reader-Supported Issue

A Handwritten Journal Called

Pens  ✎  Paper  ✎  Ink  ✎  Letters

The Great Dot Grid Versus Lined Debate

By Oskar Lindqvist June 19, 2026 Paper & Notebooks 1 min read 447 Views 8 Comments

We asked twelve writers which ruling they reach for, and nobody agreed.

Taken on a grey morning in Penhollow.

Few topics fill our inbox faster. Dot grid people call lined paper rigid; lined people call dot grid indecisive. Both sides are right about something.

Where each ruling wins

After a month of swapping notebooks between writers, the answer depended less on taste than on what each person was trying to write.

  • Lined for long letters and drafts.
  • Dot grid for lists, diagrams, and layouts.
  • Blank for sketches and calligraphy practice.
  • Graph for anyone who secretly loves tables.

“Sir, more than kisses, letters mingle souls; for, thus friends absent speak.”

— John Donne, “To Sir Henry Wotton” (c. 1597)

8 Comments  on this note

  1. O
    Odette Lambert Reply ›

    I laughed at the bit about losing the loupe. Mine is in a drawer I cannot find.

    1. H
      Hamid Rostami Reply ›

      Seconding this. A follow-up would be great.

    2. R
      Rufus Tennant Reply ›

      There is a good thread about this in the reader mailbag from last spring.

  2. L
    Lionel Dufresne Reply ›

    Came for the pens, stayed for the writing. Subscribed to the newsletter.

  3. C
    Clara Fenwick Reply ›

    I laughed at the bit about losing the loupe. Mine is in a drawer I cannot find.

    1. D
      Dmitri Halloran Reply ›

      Would love to see your results if you try it.

      1. N
        Nils Haraldsen Reply ›

        Would love to see your results if you try it.

  4. J
    Jonah Pemberton Reply ›

    I laughed at the bit about losing the loupe. Mine is in a drawer I cannot find.

Leave a Comment

All comments are reviewed prior to publication. Your email address will not be displayed. Fields marked * are required.